Environment Policy 14
Source: Inspectors Report For The Area Plan For The East 100123
also to entail the permanent loss of some versatile A2 agricultural land, falling within Class 3/2 as shown on the Agricultural Land Use Capability Map of the Isle of Man. This would be counter to Environment Policy 14 of the Strategic Plan. In my view, this should tell against the retention of this land as a Strategic Reserve Site.
348 I recommend that the proposal to show Site BH032 as a Strategic Reserve Site for potential residential development be deleted from the Area Plan.
349 Site GH011 consists of about 2ha of open land on the east side of Ballacollister Road, Laxey, immediately to the north of that village's existing built up area. It is allocated for residential development in the Laxey and Lonan Area Plan 2005, but is outside the existing settlement boundary of Laxey as shown in the draft Area Plan. In 2007, planning approval in principle was granted for six dwellings on this land, but this was never taken, up and has now lapsed.
350 Site GH015 is contiguous with Site GH011, to the north-east. It has an area of about 0.22ha, and is shown as woodland in the Laxey and Lonan Local Plan 2005. It is outside the settlement boundary of Laxey, as shown in the draft Area Plan.
351 In the draft Area Plan as published in May 2018, these sites were allocated for residential development. However, in the Schedule of Proposed Changes published in July 2019, the Cabinet Office indicated that they would be relegated to the status of Strategic Reserve Sites.
352 Mr M Perkins referred to current sewage problems in this area, although I understand that new provision for sewage treatment is planned for Laxey. Miss P Newton felt that the development of this land would detract from the visual amenity of Laxey. It would be visible across a wide area, and would require the removal of trees. M Turner and A Kennaugh referred to the poor access, and considered that Site GH011 should remain in agricultural use.
353 I consider that, at present, access to these sites is unsatisfactory. Ballacollister Road is a single-track lane, which would require widening to permit two vehicles to pass one another without difficulty. Its junction with the A2 is sub-standard.
354 In view of this, I am not convinced that these small sites should be considered as providing an appropriate location for a sustainable extension to Laxey. Furthermore, I have seen no evidence that there is a local housing need that would justify the extension of this settlement into the surrounding countryside. In the circumstances, I am not persuaded that there is a case for either site to be reserved for future development.
355 I recommend that neither Site GH011 nor Site GH015 be allocated for residential use in the Area Plan, either for immediate development, or as strategic reserve land.
356 Site GH020 comprises about 1.5ha of undeveloped land within the existing settlement boundary of Laxey, as shown in the draft Area Plan. It is within an established housing area, in a hillside location, on the northern side of the village. It was allocated for residential development in both the 1982 Development Plan and the Laxey and Lonan Local Plan 2005. In the draft Area Plan as published in May 2018, it was proposed as a residential allocation for immediate development. However, in the Schedule of Proposed Changes published in July 2019, the Cabinet Office indicated that it would be relegated to the status of a Strategic Reserve Site.
357 Mr M Perkins referred to the surface water drainage problems in Laxey. There had been recent flooding events in the village and these could be expected to increase in frequency and intensity as a result of climate change. Development of this site would exacerbate this problem, by accelerating the rate of run-off from the newly installed hard surfaces. The soils here are shallow and overlie rock. As a result soakaways quickly overflow.
358 During the course of the inquiry, there was a serious flood event in Laxey, and it is important that the risk of further such events should not be exacerbated. In my view it would be poor planning to provide for the development of this site without being certain that measures could be taken to ensure that there would be no increase in the rate of surface water run-off. On the evidence available to me, I am not certain that this would be possible. In the circumstances, I consider that the allocation of this site should be deleted from the Area Plan.
359 I recommend that Site GH020 be deleted from the Area Plan as either a specific housing allocation or as a reserve site for residential development.
360 This is a parcel of about 0.8ha of undeveloped land. The draft Area Plan shows it to fall outside the Existing Settlement Boundary of Laxey, which runs along its northern and
31
Citations
96.6%
Approval Rate
2023
Peak Year
Malew
Top Parish
Change of use of part of Field 425312 to extend residential curtilage (retrospective)
Replacement of existing utility room with single storey extension linking the dwelling house and existing detached garage, and extension of residential curtilage
Erection of an agricultural building
Extension of residential curtilage (change of use from paddock to residential garden) (retrospective)
Extension of residential curtilage (retrospective)
Replacement stables and field store
Erection of a new dwelling
Extension to the curtilage to create a landscaped garden with terraced decking, external sauna, spa pools and glazed garden pod. Creation of a service yard and erection of a prefabricated service building to house the filtration equipment for the proposed spa pools
Erection of a stable block
Erection of three polytunnels, and construction of pond and hardstanding area.