23 August 2007 · Planning Committee initially; appeal dismissed by independent inspector John S Turner, confirmed by Mr. D. M. W. Butt, MLC (deputy to Minister)
Brae Villa, Tromode Road, Douglas, Isle Of Man, IM2 5ej
The proposal involved demolishing the existing post-WWI dwelling at Brae Villa and replacing it with a three-storey building containing 11 one-bedroom flats, 14 basement parking spaces, and 3 external spaces.
Click a button above to find applications similar to this one.
See how this application compares to similar ones — policies, conditions, and outcomes side by side.
The Planning Officer assessed the indicative three-storey block of 11 one-bedroom flats as a 'considerable over-development' with a bulky form close to the highway (6m setback vs existing 5m), side bo…
General Policy 2
Requires development to respect local character and amenity. Officer noted proposal conformed to residential zoning but failed on bulk, scale and green space in this transition area.
Housing Policy 5
Requires 25% affordable housing (min 2-bed, 63 sq m) in developments of 8+ dwellings. Indicative 1-bed flats (55 sq m) could not comply without redesign; Estates Directorate confirmed 3 units needed for first-time buyers under House Purchase Assistance Scheme.
Housing Policy 6
Mentioned but not specifically tested in refusal reasons.
Recreation Policy 3
Requires landscaped amenity space per Appendix 6 (48 sq m per 1-bed dwelling = 528 sq m total). Indicative plans showed no provision for this quantum.
Transport Policy 7
Parking provision (14 basement + 3 external) accords with standards; visibility splays achievable per Highways.
Standard comments / note received
Standard comments / note received
Comments received
Required visibility splays of 2.0 x 90m; later indicated could meet standards
3 affordable homes required (2-bed, min 63 sq m); redesign needed as proposal shows small 1-bed units
Deferred / no comment