9 June 2005 · Planning Committee
Ballnalargy Cottage, Dalby, Isle Of Man, IM5 3bp
The proposal involved converting two adjoining barns next to Ballnalargy Cottage, a detached rural dwelling, into holiday accommodation, described as a three-bedroom, six-person self-catering tourist unit.
Click a button above to find applications similar to this one.
See how this application compares to similar ones — policies, conditions, and outcomes side by side.
The officer determined the barns did not comply with Planning Circular 3/89 'Renovation of buildings in the countryside' because they are not registered or worthy of registration, lack particular arch…
Planning Circular 3/89 Renovation of Buildings in the Countryside
The policy permits renovation of countryside buildings that are registered/worthy of registration, have architectural/historic/social interest, contribute beneficially to countryside character, are redundant, and capable of conversion without substantial rebuilding. The officer assessed the barns as failing all criteria: not registered/worthy, no special interest, no beneficial contribution to character, one not redundant (used for storage), and no survey proving structural viability for conversion to holiday use without rebuilding.
Western Sector Written Statement (Planning Circular 8/91)
Referenced by Registration and Grading Commission as complied with for encouraging quality tourist accommodation. Officer did not explicitly assess against it but focused on 3/89 non-compliance overriding this support.
The proposal complies with Planning Circular 3/89 and Western Sector Plan 8/91; in sympathy with policy to encourage quality self-catering tourist accommodation in the Manx countryside; fully supports the application.
Although deficient in roofing the remains are substantial and vernacular and redundant, and on the whole the proposal seems acceptable on the 'not too bad scale'.