Loading document...
==== PAGE 2 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
2
Control sheet
Job number: EV 23_06 Title: Netherby – Bat Survey Report Client: Hartford Homes Prepared by: Sarah Hickey - Ecologist Verified by: Adam Denard – Senior Ecologist Date of Issue: August 2023 Version: 1 Revisions: 0 Status: FINAL
This report is prepared by Ecology Vannin Consultancy Services for the sole and exclusive use of Hartford Homes and their contractors in response to their particular instructions. No liability is accepted for any costs, claims or losses arising from the use of this report or any part thereof for any purpose other than that for which it was specifically prepared or by any party other than Hartford Homes. Any biological records for wildlife found in survey will eventually be submitted to Manx Biological Recording Partnership.
Ecology Vannin Consultancy Services is the trading name for Wildlife Limited, Reg Company No: 077379C. Wildlife Limited is a wholly owned subsidiary of Manx Wildlife Trust (MWT), Reg Company No: 005297C.This report does not prevent MWT pursuing its charitable objectives in relation to planning.
This report has been prepared by an environmental specialist and does not purport to provide legal advice. You may wish to take separate legal advice.
The information which we have prepared and provided is true and has been prepared and provided in accordance with the BS42020 2013 and Chartered Institute of Ecology and Environmental Management’s Code of Professional Conduct and guidelines for preliminary ecological appraisals (CIEEM 2017). We confirm that the opinions expressed are our true and professional bona fide opinions.
Signed (Author) Signed (QA)
Ecology Vannin: 7-8 Market Place, Peel, Isle of Man.
==== PAGE 3 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
3
Executive Summary
Two emergence surveys were undertaken at a site known as Netherby, Castletown, Isle of Man. This report offers advice on the mitigation necessary to avoid offences under the IOM Wildlife Act 1990 (as amended), following the mitigation hierarchy of ‘avoid, minimise and compensate’. It also offers advice to enhance the site for bats and other wildlife.
Key constraints and mitigation are:
• Lighting plan to minimise impact to bats. • Installation of integrated bat boxes into the new buildings. • Compensatory planting. The results of this report are valid for 2 years, after which a re-assessment may be required.
Biographies
Sarah Hickey BSc (Hons) MRes, ACIEEM is an ecologist with several years’ experience in baseline ecological survey and assessment and specialist protected species surveys for bats, Common Lizard and Common Frog. Sarah holds a master’s degree in Research in the Natural Environment from the University of Edinburgh and has contributed to the Independent Climate Action Report for the IOM Government (Appendix 10 (a) Peatlands).
Adam Denard BSc (Hons) has been a professional ecologist for over 10 years, with particular emphasis on recording and assessing habitats in England and the Isle of Man for their potential to support protected species. Adam regularly produces professional ecological reports within the Isle of Man planning system for ecological appraisals, impact assessments, mitigation plans and specialist protected species surveys.
==== PAGE 4 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
4
Contents
1.0 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 5 2.0 Methodology ............................................................................................................... 5 3.0 Results ....................................................................................................................... 6 4.0 Discussion .................................................................................................................. 7 5.0 Recommendations ..................................................................................................... 8 Appendix I: Survey Results ................................................................................................. 10
Glossary
BCT
Bat Conservation Trust MBG Manx Bat Group MBRP Manx Biodiversity Recording Partnership PEA
Preliminary Ecological Appraisal PEAR Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Report PRA
Preliminary Roost Assessment PRF Potential Roost Feature
==== PAGE 5 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
5
1.0 Introduction
1.1 Ecology Vannin was commissioned by Hartford Homes to undertake two bat emergence surveys on a house known as Netherby, Castletown, Isle of Man. This is in relation to recommendations made in the Protected Species Report – Preliminary Roost Assessment Bats (MWT Consultancy, February 2022). Ecology Vannin was also commissioned to undertake a roost assessment of Tree 4618 to satisfy planning condition 4.
1.2 Emergence surveys were undertaken on 26/06/23 and 20/07/23 by assistant ecologist Laura Strand and Ecology Vannin field assistants, under the guidance of senior ecologist Adam Denard. The roost assessment of Tree 4618 was undertaken by ecologist Sarah Hickey on 11/08/23.
2.0 Methodology
2.1 Two emergence surveys were undertaken on the building as the preliminary roost assessment deemed it to be of moderate suitability for bats. Bat passes were recorded using Ananbat Scout and Peersonic RPA3 handheld devices. Results were later processed using the autoclassifier function in Sonobat 30 software. Autoclassifier results were manually reviewed for any obvious erroneous identification of species. Video footage was recorded using Sionyx Aurora Sport night vision cameras and Infra-red lighting.
2.2 Surveyors were positioned to cover potential access and egress points (see Figure 1 overleaf).
2.3 A thorough inspection of Tree 4618 was undertaken using a Rigid CA300 endoscope.
2.4 All of the above was conducted following best practice as described in Bat Surveys for Professional Ecologists (BCT, 2016 (3rd Ed)).
Limitations
2.5 Data collected by the bat detector at survey point 1 during the first emergence survey was corrupted. This was not deemed to be a significant limitation as the surveyor also made notes of bats heard and seen during the survey.
==== PAGE 6 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
6
3.0 Results
Emergence Surveys
3.1 The location of survey points is shown in Figure 1 below. Full results of the emergence surveys can be found in Appendix I.
3.2 Table 1 below and 2 overleaf show a summary of the emergence surveys. It should be noted that the number of bat passes does not indicate the number of bats. A single bat can pass a survey point several times, resulting in multiple passes recorded. The number of bats seen by a surveyor at a single time indicates the minimum number of bats recorded during the survey.
Table 1: Summary of bat survey results at Netherby 26/06/23 Date: 26/06/23 Survey time: 21.55 – 23.30 Weather conditions: 16oC, overcast, light SW wind. Previous weather: Warm and sunny. Time of sunset: 21.55 Time of first bat pass: 22:27 Comments: At least three bats seen foraging around the house and gardens.
Species Surveyor 1 2 3 4 5 Common Pipistrelle 38 (unconfirmed species) 4 42 20 36 Leisler’s Bat 0 1 2 3
==== PAGE 7 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
7
Table 2: Summary of bat survey results at Netherby 20/07/23 Date: 20/07/23 Survey time: 21.55 – 23.30 Weather conditions: Overcast, damp, 14oC Previous weather: Warm and sunny. Time of sunset: 21.30 Time of first bat pass: 22:03 Comments: At least two bats seen foraging around the house and gardens.
Species Surveyor 1 2 3 4 5 Common Pipistrelle 23 11 97 69 37 Leisler’s Bat 3 8 1 1 1
Roost Inspection
3.3 The roost inspection showed that the feature potential roost feature (PRF) identified in Tree 4618 in the Preliminary Ecological Appraisal Report (PEAR) (MWT Consultancy, June 2021) was of low suitability for bats. The tree is a stump approximately 3m tall, with lateral branches and the PRF is a small gap near the top of the stump. There were no bats found to be using the feature and no evidence that it had been used by bats.
Photograph 1: PRF in Tree 4618
4.0 Discussion
4.1 Two species of bats were recorded during both surveys, Common Pipistrelle (Pipistrellus pipistrellus) and Leisler’s Bat (Nyctalus leisleri). The total number of bat passes recorded on each survey was higher at the front of the house than at the rear and represented at least three bats on the first survey and at least two bats on the second survey.
4.2 The surveys indicate that the site is used by foraging bats, with bats noted flying from the trees in the western part of the site and past the front of the house, apparently looping around the house and gardens. Trees and shrubs surrounding the site
==== PAGE 8 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
8
provide shelter and food for invertebrate prey and the moderate number of bat passes recorded suggests that the site is has importance for foraging bats.
4.3 No bats were seen to emerge from any of the buildings during either survey. It is unlikely that the buildings are used by roosting bats, although bats are a mobile species and can move between roosts for a number of reasons.
4.4 The PRF in Tree 4618 is of low suitability for bats and there was no evidence that it had been used by bats, although any evidence may have been degraded by the weather. It is unlikely that this feature is used by roosting bats, however bats are a mobile species and the use of the PRF cannot be ruled out.
5.0 Recommendations
5.1 Table 3 below shows the necessary constraints and mitigation for the re- development of the site. This follows the hierarchy of ‘avoid, minimise, restore and (as a last resort) compensate’ (CIEEM, 2018).
Table 3: Constraints and mitigation for the development of the site. Ecological feature Constraint Mitigation Bats Schedule 5, IOM Wildlife Act 1990 (as amended).
Environment Policy 4 Avoid • Trees within and surrounding the site should be retained where possible for their value to foraging bats. Minimise • Tree 4618 should be removed without cutting through the PRF (which is near the top of the tree stump). The part of the tree with the PRF should be placed on the ground for at least 24 hours, with the PRF positioned so that any bats using it can escape. • If any bats are found during any works, work must stop immediately and advice sought from MWT Consultancy, Manx Bat Group or DEFA. • Lighting plans should be designed to avoid impacting bats by use of directional lighting and avoiding lighting in key areas for bats, such as near tree and shrub borders (refer to BCT guidance on bats and artificial lighting). Compensate • The removal of any trees should be compensated for by the replacement planting of suitable native species or those with known benefits to wildlife. • The removal of any flowers and shrubs should be compensated for by planting species with known benefits to wildlife. • Artificial roost provision should be incorporated into new buildings in suitable locations (at eaves level, away from direct light sources and on sunny aspect walls near tree and shrub cover). These should be integrated boxes suitable for crevice-roosting species, such as these.
==== PAGE 9 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
9
Locations and specifications to be arranged between Ecology Vannin and the design team.
6.2 There is potential to improve the site for bats with the following enhancements:
• Plant a range of flowering shrubs beneficial to wildlife, such as Lavender, Hebe, Currant and Ivy. Avoid any invasive non-native species. • Plant trees along the site boundary which are beneficial to wildlife, such as Hawthorn, Crab Apple, Elder, Blackthorn, Wild Cherry and Hazel. • New grass areas could be created using a low-fertility substrate, such a crushed concrete. These could then be planted and seeded with a wildflower-rich grass mix and left to grow during the spring and summer months to attract pollinators.
REFERENCES
Bat Conservation Trust (2016.) Bat Surveys for Professional Ecologists – 3rd Edition. BCT, London.
CIEEM (2017). Guidelines for Preliminary Ecological Appraisal, 2nd edition. Chartered Institute of Ecology and Environmental Management, Winchester.
DEFA (2015). Managing our natural wealth – The Isle of Man’s first Biodiversity Strategy 2015-2025 – GD 2015/0049. IoM Gov, Douglas.
Isle of Man Government Cabinet Office (2016). The Isle of Man Strategic Plan 2016 – 2016/0060. IoM Government, Douglas.
==== PAGE 10 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
10
Appendix I: Survey Results
26/06/23
1 Filename HiF LoF Species Manual ID SppAccp #Maj #Accp ~Spp 1st 2nd 3rd 2023-06-26 22-27- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 12 16 Pippip Pipnat
2023-06-26 22-29- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 20 20 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-30- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-31- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-33- HiLo.wav 1 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
2023-06-26 22-33-noID.wav
1 1 Pippip Pippip
2023-06-26 22-35-Nyclei.wav 1 Nyclei 4 6 Nyclei Nycnoc
2023-06-26 22-35- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-36- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-37- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-40- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 27 28 Pippip Myodau 2023-06-26 22-41-HiF.wav 1 Pippip
1 1 Pippip Pippip
2023-06-26 22-41- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-43-HiF.wav 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
==== PAGE 11 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
11
2023-06-26 22-43- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
2023-06-26 22-50-Nycnoc.wav 1 Nycnoc 9 9 Nycnoc
2023-06-26 22-50- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 13 13 Pippip
2023-06-26 23-03- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
2023-06-26 23-04- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 6 7 Pippip Pipnat
2023-06-26 23-05- Pipnat.wav 1
Pipnat 12 12 Pipnat
2023-06-26 23-10- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
2023-06-26 23-12- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 27 28 Pippip Pipnat
2023-06-26 23-16- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
2023-06-26 23-19- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 26 26 Pippip
2023-06-26 23-26-HiF.wav 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
2023-06-26 23-28- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
2023-06-26 23-29- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 9 9 Pippip
2 26/06/2022 20:53 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:53 1
Pippip 13 13 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:53 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:53 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:54 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:54 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
==== PAGE 12 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
12
26/06/2022 20:54 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:54 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:54 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:54 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
26/06/2022 20:56 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
26/06/2022 21:16 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
26/06/2022 21:16 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
26/06/2022 21:16 1
Pippip 7 8 Pippip Pipnat
26/06/2022 21:16 1
3 5 Pippip/Pipnat Pippip Pipnat
26/06/2022 21:17 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
26/06/2022 21:25 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
26/06/2022 21:25 1
Pipnat 8 12 Pipnat Pippip
26/06/2022 21:29 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
26/06/2022 21:32 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
3 26/06/2023 22:42 1
Pippip 13 13 Pippip
26/06/2023 22:43 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
26/06/2023 22:43 1
Pippip 22 22 Pippip
26/06/2023 22:47 1 Nyclei 8 8 Nyclei
26/06/2023 22:50 1
Pippip 9 9 Pippip
26/06/2023 22:50 1 Nycnoc 8 8 Nycnoc
26/06/2023 23:02 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
26/06/2023 23:03 1
Pippip 16 16 Pippip
26/06/2023 23:03 1
Pippip 14 14 Pippip
26/06/2023 23:05 1
Pipnat 28 28 Pipnat
26/06/2023 23:10 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
26/06/2023 23:12 1
Pippip 17 23 Pippip Pipnat
26/06/2023 23:16 1
Pippip 6 7 Pippip Pipnat
26/06/2023 23:18 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
==== PAGE 13 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
13
26/06/2023 23:19 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
26/06/2023 23:25 1
2 3 Pippip/Pipnat Pippip Pipnat
26/06/2023 23:25 1
Pipnat 13 15 Pipnat Pippip
26/06/2023 23:26 1
3 4 Pippip Pippip Pipnat
26/06/2023 23:29 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
4 26/06/2023 23:32 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
26/06/2023 23:32 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
26/06/2023 23:32 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
26/06/2023 23:33 1
Pippip 9 9 Pippip
20/07/23
Filename HiF LoF Species Manual ID SppAccp #Maj #Accp ~Spp 1st 2nd 3rd 2023-07-20 22-09-Nyclei.wav 1 Nyclei 9 12 Nyclei Nycnoc
2023-07-20 22-10- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-16- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-17- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 17 17 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-21- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 26 26 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-24- Nyclei.wav 1 1 Nyclei 12 12 Nyclei Pippip
2023-07-20 22-24- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-26- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
==== PAGE 14 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
14
2023-07-20 22-28-Nyclei.wav 1 Nyclei 26 28 Nyclei Nycnoc
2023-07-20 22-28- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 27 27 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-30- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-34- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 32 32 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-35- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-36- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-52-LoF.wav 1
1 2 Nycnoc/Nyclei Nyclei Nycnoc
2023-07-20 22-53- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-54- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 32 32 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-58- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-59- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 32 32 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-01- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 32 32 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-02- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-03- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 32 32 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-04- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-07-HiF.wav 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
2023-07-20 23-07- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 32 32 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-08-noID.wav
1 1 Pippip Pippip
==== PAGE 15 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
15
2 19/07/2022 21:59 1
1 1 Nyclei Nyclei
19/07/2022 22:16 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
19/07/2022 22:17 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
19/07/2022 22:29 1
Pippip 13 13 Pippip
19/07/2022 22:34 1 Nyclei 3 4 Nyclei Nycnoc
19/07/2022 22:35 1
Pippip 19 20 Pippip Pippyg
20/07/2022 22:25 1 Nyclei 9 12 Nyclei Nycnoc
20/07/2022 22:29 1 Nyclei 22 25 Nyclei Nycnoc
20/07/2022 22:29 1 Nyclei 15 18 Nyclei Nycnoc
20/07/2022 22:30
1 1 Nyclei Nyclei
20/07/2022 22:34 1
Pippip 14 14 Pippip
20/07/2022 22:44
1 1 Nyclei Nyclei
20/07/2022 22:54 1
Pippip 30 30 Pippip
20/07/2022 22:59 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2022 23:01 1
Pippip 23 23 Pippip
20/07/2022 23:03 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
20/07/2022 23:04 1
2 2 Nycnoc Nycnoc
20/07/2022 23:08 1
Pippip 7 7 Pippip
20/07/2022 23:08 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
3 20/07/2023 22:02 1
Pippip 5 6 Pippip Pippyg
20/07/2023 22:08 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:09 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:09 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:12 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:12 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:12 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:13 1
Pippip 20 20 Pippip
==== PAGE 16 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
16
20/07/2023 22:14 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:14 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:14 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 24 24 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 14 14 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 17 17 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 27 27 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 23 23 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 26 26 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 20 20 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 20 20 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 27 27 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 30 30 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 30 30 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 23 23 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
==== PAGE 17 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
17
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:20 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:20 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:20 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:21 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:21 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:21 1 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:21 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1 1 Pippip 5 5 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
2 3 Pippyg Pippyg Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1 1 Pippip 5 5 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1 1 Pippip 4 4 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1 1 Pippip 4 4 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1
Pippip 6 7 Pippip Pippyg
20/07/2023 22:23 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:24 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:24 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:24 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
==== PAGE 18 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
18
20/07/2023 22:24 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:25 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 22 22 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 26 26 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:27 1 1 Pippip 14 14 Pippip Nyclei Nycnoc 20/07/2023 22:27 1
Pippip 16 16 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:28 1
1 1 Pippip/ Pippip
20/07/2023 22:28 1
Pippip 17 17 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:29 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:29 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:30 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:32 1 1 Pippip 5 5 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:32 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:33 1
2 2 Nycnoc Nycnoc
20/07/2023 22:34 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:39 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:40 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:44 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:47 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:51 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:51 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:52 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:53 1 1
1 2 Pipnat/Pippip Pippip Pipnat
20/07/2023 22:54 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
20/07/2023 22:58 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:58 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
==== PAGE 19 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
19
20/07/2023 23:01 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
20/07/2023 23:02 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 23:02
1 1 Pippip/ Pippip
4 19/07/2023 22:48 1
Pippip 16 17 Pippip Pipnat
19/07/2023 22:58 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:02 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:08 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:10 1
Pippip 17 17 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:12 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:12 1
Pippip 17 17 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:13 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:13 1
Pippip 23 23 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:14 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 16 16 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 9 9 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:15 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 24 25 Pippip Pippyg
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:16 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 16 16 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:17 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
==== PAGE 20 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
20
20/07/2023 22:18 1
Pippip 9 9 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1
Pippip 17 17 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:19 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:20 1
Pippip 16 16 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:20 1
Pippip 23 23 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:20 1
Pippip 19 19 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:21 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:21 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:21 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 13 13 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:22 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1
Pippip 6 6 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1 1 Pippip 14 14 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:23 1
Pippip 22 22 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:24 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:24 1
Pippip 14 14 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:24 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:25 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:25 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 9 9 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:26 1
Pippip 18 18 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:27 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
==== PAGE 21 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
21
20/07/2023 22:27 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:27 1 1 Nyclei 12 15 Nyclei Pippip Nycnoc 20/07/2023 22:28 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:28 1
Pippip 30 30 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:29 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:29 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:29 1
Pippip 26 26 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:32 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:35 1
Pippip 13 13 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:44 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:50 1
Pippip 22 22 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:51 1
Pippip 31 31 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:54 1 1 Pippip 17 19 Pippip Pipnat Nycnoc 20/07/2023 22:58 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
20/07/2023 22:58 1
Pippip 13 13 Pippip
20/07/2023 23:00 1
Pippip 16 16 Pippip
5 2023-07-20 22-03- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 8 8 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-09-HiF.wav 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
2023-07-20 22-11- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 7 7 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-13-HiF.wav 1
3 3 Pippip Pippip
2023-07-20 22-13- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-14- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 21 21 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-15- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
==== PAGE 22 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
22
2023-07-20 22-16- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-17-HiF.wav 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
2023-07-20 22-17- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 20 20 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-18-HiF.wav 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
2023-07-20 22-18- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 9 9 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-19-HiF.wav 1
1 1 Pippip Pippip
2023-07-20 22-19- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-20- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 22 22 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-21- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 10 10 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-22- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 7 7 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-24- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 28 28 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-25- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 24 24 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-26- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 20 20 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-27- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 24 25 Pippip Pippyg
2023-07-20 22-28- Nyclei.wav 1 1 Nyclei 12 13 Nyclei Pippip Nycnoc 2023-07-20 22-28- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 22 22 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-29- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 12 12 Pippip
==== PAGE 23 ====
Ecology Vannin Netherby Bat Survey
23
2023-07-20 22-30- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-31- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 14 14 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-33- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-36- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 15 15 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-45- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 29 29 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-51- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 7 7 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-52- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 25 25 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-54- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 4 4 Pippip
2023-07-20 22-55-HiF.wav 1
2 2 Pippip Pippip
2023-07-20 22-55- Pippip.wav 1 1 Pippip 28 28 Pippip Nyclei
2023-07-20 22-59- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 17 17 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-01- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 26 26 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-03- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 11 11 Pippip
2023-07-20 23-04- Pippip.wav 1
Pippip 5 5 Pippip
Copyright in submitted documents remains with their authors. Request removal