**Document:** AP250011 Garff Commissioners Appeal Statement
**Application:** AP25/0011 — Appeal against the refusal for erection of replacement dwelling
**Decision:** Appeal accepted - PA APPROVED
**Decision Date:** 2025-10-17
**Parish:** Lezayre
**Document Type:** appeal / appeal_statement
**Source:** https://planningportal.im/a/88414-lezayre-thie-dhorlish-replacement-dwelling/documents/1141996

---

# AP250011 Garff Commissioners Appeal Statement

|Garff Sheading<br><br>LAXEY LONAN<br><br>MAUGHOLD<br><br>Garff Sheading|Garff Commissioners<br><br>Barrantee Garff<br><br>35 New Road, Laxey, Isle of Man, IM4 7BG. Telephone: (01624) 861241 Fax: (01624) 862623 Email:admin@garff.im www.garff.im|
|---|---|

Mr Andrew Joyce Planning Appeals Administration Cabinet Office Government Office Douglas Isle of Man IM1 3PN

12th May 2025

Dear Mr Joyce Please could the comments below be forwarded to the Inspector appointed to consider the appeal on the following application:

|Application Number: PA 25/90119/B AP25/0011 Appeal against refusal for erection of replacement dwelling. Thie Dhorlish, Rhenab road, Cornaa, Maughold IM7 1EL<br><br>|
|---|

The Commissioners Submission relating to the Appeal begins overleaf.

Appeal Submission from Garff District Commissioners Application Number: PA 25/90119/B AP25/0011 Appeal against refusal for erection of replacement dwelling. Thie Dhorlish, Rhenab road, Cornaa, Maughold IM7 1EL

In their response at the application stage the Commissioners recorded no objection to the proposals.

Members note the detailed and accurate analysis presented by the Planning Authority regarding the status of the site as set out in the reasons for refusal. Whilst they respect the logic of this, the Board wishes to reiterate the content of their initial statement of May 7th 2025 which reads:

###### There were no objections to these proposals. Members felt that the design and scope of the proposed dwelling were relatively in-keeping with the previous cottage and would not be inappropriate in thislocation.

It is the view of the Commission that the dwelling would present similar characteristics to the original dilapidated cottage and would therefore have minimal impact on the character of the area. As a consequence, the Commissioners do not object to the proposals.

One concern of the Commissioners is that in future years their may be a change in approach in regard to the status of the site; in that circumstance, they are concerned that any design that came forward at that time may not as adequately reflect the character of this sensitive location - which overlooks one of the Island’s premier Glens.

The Commissioners thank the Planning Inspector for considering their views in regard to this matter.

redacted

Martin Royle Clerk, Garff District Commissioners

---

*Data sourced from the Isle of Man public planning register under the [Isle of Man Open Government Licence](https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/).*
*Canonical page: https://planningportal.im/a/88414-lezayre-thie-dhorlish-replacement-dwelling/documents/1141996*